Advice7 min read
The five mistakes that cost the most marks in the commentaire
They turn up in almost every paper, including those of good students. Spotting them often means gaining two to four marks.
When I mark bac papers, one thing strikes me every year: the same mistakes come back, sometimes in papers that took a great deal of work. These are not mistakes of knowledge. They are mistakes of method, and they can be corrected.
1. Retelling the text instead of analysing it
This is by far the most costly mistake. The student rewords the text in their own words, sometimes adds an adjective of appreciation, and moves on to the next line. The marker reads a paper that says nothing about the text: it repeats it.
The test is simple. Take any sentence in the paper and ask yourself: have I just learnt something about the text, or have I just reread the text?
2. Producing a catalogue of figures of speech
The student has learnt to spot devices, and spots them conscientiously: a metaphor, an alliteration, a ternary rhythm. Then they stop there, as if naming were enough.
Spotting a metaphor earns nothing. Explaining what it does, and how it serves the text, earns a great deal.
Every device mentioned must be followed by an interpretation. A good habit is to forbid yourself from writing the name of a device without writing, in the same sentence, the effect it produces.
3. Following the text from start to finish
The commentaire composé is not an explication linéaire. A plan that starts at the first line and ends at the last is not a plan: it is a stroll. The marker expects lines of analysis, in other words ideas about the text, each fed by elements taken from different places.
A useful benchmark
If your two lines of analysis could be titled “the beginning of the text” and “the end of the text”, you do not have a plan yet. Look instead at what the text does: it celebrates, it denounces, it unsettles, it stages a contradiction.
4. Quoting too much, and quoting badly
Long quotations copied out are spotted at once: they fill the paper without enriching it. Conversely, a paper without quotations proves nothing of what it claims.
- Quote briefly: a few words are almost always enough
- Build the quotation into the sentence instead of setting it alongside
- Analyse it immediately afterwards, in the same sentence if possible
- Vary the places in the text that the quotations come from
5. Managing the four hours badly
Every year, papers arrive unfinished, with a third line of analysis reduced to a few lines or no conclusion at all. Almost always, the cause is the same: two hours spent on rough work.
A breakdown that works: one hour of reading and rough work, two and a half hours of writing, thirty minutes of proofreading. This breakdown is practised in real conditions, several times a year, until it becomes automatic.
What these five points have in common
None of these mistakes has anything to do with the student’s intelligence or culture. They are habits, formed for lack of precise feedback on their own papers. That is exactly what one-to-one support corrects: not adding knowledge, but changing reflexes.
